The Legacy of Edith O’Hara & 13th Street Repertory Company

 




In trendy Greenwich Village, a battle is unfolding over the future of a modest three-story Greek Revival rowhouse at 50 West 13th Street. With its intricate cast-iron portico, this unassuming structure has been more than just a building; it's been a beacon for the avant-garde, a sanctuary for the aspiring, and a home for groundbreaking theater. Yet, in January 2021, when Village Preservation approached the city's Landmarks Preservation Commission, they were met with a disheartening response: the building, they were told, did not possess the architectural grandeur to merit landmark status. The Commission did, however, leave a window open, suggesting that the building's "cultural significance," particularly with the Off-Off Broadway theater movement, required further exploration.


The 13th Street Repertory Theatre, housed within this very building, has been a cradle for theatrical innovation for decades. This was the stage where Richard Dreyfuss and Chazz Palminteri, among others, honed their crafts in their nascent stages. It's where "Line," a one-act play by Israel Horovitz — whose son would go on to fame with the Beastie Boys — broke Off-Off Broadway records with a run spanning over 40 years. This venue also saw the debut of "The Indian Wants the Bronx" and "Boy Meets Boy," the latter being New York’s first hit gay musical, conceptualized by Englishman Bill Solly who lived just upstairs from the theater.


Behind all this creative ferment was Ms. Edith O'Hara, the matriarch and artistic soul of the 13th Street Repertory Company. Until her passing in the fall of 2020 at the remarkable age of 103, Ms. O'Hara was a towering figure in the theater community, nurturing talent and offering a platform for plays that mainstream venues often overlooked. Her legacy is intertwined with that of the building she cherished and fought for. Today, the future of this historic site hangs in the balance. As the Preservation Commission hesitates, the specter of the wrecking ball looms large, threatening to erase a vital piece of New York’s Broadway theater. 







The struggle to save the historic rowhouse has taken a dramatic turn, unveiling layers of history that extend far beyond its storied days as the cradle of avant-garde theatre. Village Preservation, a staunch advocate for the building's landmark status, has unearthed compelling evidence linking the property to Jacob Day, an influential African-American businessman and a key figure in the city’s Underground Railroad network.


Jacob Day's tenure at the house spanned from 1858 to 1884, a period when he emerged as one of New York City's wealthiest African-American residents. By 1871, he boasted a net worth exceeding $75,000 — approximately $1.6 million in today's currency. His prominence extended into the spiritual realm as the longtime treasurer of the Abyssinian Baptist Church, then located a stone's throw away at 166 Waverly Place. This church is recognized as the city’s second oldest Black church, marking the neighborhood as a significant center for African-American heritage.


These revelations have added a rich layer to the narrative of 13th Street Theater, transforming it from a mere theatrical landmark to a beacon of African-American history and the fight for freedom. This discovery comes at a time when the building's future is under threat by modern development pressures. Currently owned by Atiti Jariwala, CEO of Bridgeton Capital, the rowhouse's unique architectural elements, including its intricate cast-iron portico and window fire escapes, have been removed — a move that has alarmed preservationists and historians alike.


The building's past ownership reflects a microcosm of New York's complex real estate dynamics. In 2021, ownership transitioned from White Knight Ltd., partly owned by the children of Edith O'Hara and partly by Stephan Loewentheil and his ex-wife, Beth Farber. The O'Haras and Mr. Loewentheil endured a protracted legal battle over the property, culminating in an agreement that allowed Ms. O'Hara and her theater to remain until her death in 2020. This marked a somber close to the vibrant life of the 13th Street Repertory Theatre.


With no hearing date set by the Landmarks Commission as of June 2024, the urgency for action grows. The case for landmarking the building is now twofold: it stands as both a testament to New York’s theatrical innovation and a crucial piece of the city's African-American heritage, particularly its role in the Underground Railroad.


Village Preservation is rallying support, urging those who value history and culture to join the fight to preserve this irreplaceable site. Their campaign is not just about saving a building; it's about preserving a narrative that embodies the struggles and triumphs of diverse communities that have shaped New York City’s unique cultural fabric.


For those moved by this cause, Village Preservation offers comprehensive information on how to get involved on their website. This is more than a preservation effort; it's a call to honor and protect our shared history, ensuring that stories like those of Jacob Day and the pioneering artists of the 13th Street Repertory Theatre continue to inspire future generations. 



The question now is whether the city recognizes the full measure of this building's worth, not just for its past contributions, but for the potential stories yet to be told within its walls. As this drama plays out, the hope is that wisdom and a respect for history will prevail, allowing this cornerstone of New York’s theatrical world to continue inspiring and influencing for years to come.








Sources:



1. Gill, J. (2021, March 12). Rescuing an Off-Off Broadway Theater With a Storied Past. NYTimes.

2. Barron, J. (2024, June 20). The Fight to Save a Rowhouse With Ties to Theatrical History. NYTimes.

3. The Playwright's Companion. (1995). United States: Feedback Theatrebooks. p.184

4. The Best American Short Plays 2009-2010. (2011). United States: Applause Theatre & Cinema Books. p.xxii

5. Why the Theatre: In Personal Essays, College Teachers, Actors, Directors, and Playwrights Tell Why the Theatre Is So Vital to Them. (2020). United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis. p.146

6. The Best American Short Plays 2007-2008. (2009). United States: Applause Theatre & Cinema Books.

7. Demastes, W. (2017). Understanding John Guare. United States: University of South Carolina Press.

8. DeVore, J. (2024). Theatre Kids: A True Tale of Off-Off Broadway. United States: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

9. Laermer, R. (2002). Native's Guide to New York: Advice with Attitude for People who Live Here-- and Visitors We Like. United Kingdom: W.W. Norton. p.249

10. Belovitch, B. (2018). Trans Figured: My Journey from Boy to Girl to Woman to Man. United States: Skyhorse Publishing.


Location: 50 W 13th St, New York, NY 10011, USA

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Inside the Old Remington Munitions Factory

Image
Over the years, I have had the opportunity to visit the Remington Munitions Factory three times, each visit a unique experience. The first time, I ventured there alone, driven by curiosity to explore what remained of the once-bustling industrial complex. Back then, the neighborhood was far from welcoming, and my solo exploration felt risky. However, the allure of the factory’s history and its remnants was too strong to resist. Upon arrival, the decay was evident. The complex was a shadow of its former self, ravaged by time and neglect. Scrap metal scavengers had stripped the buildings of valuable copper, steel, and iron. Every surface was a canvas for graffiti, a mix of juvenile doodles and more elaborate street art left by local kids and adventurous visitors. A fire in 2017 had already claimed part of one building, and the area had a reputation for violence, with frequent assaults and shootings on Barnum Avenue. Despite the deterioration, the factory had a certain haunting beauty, esp...
Read more

Hendey Machine Co.'s Historic Complex in Torrington

Image
  One warm day, J and I set off to explore an old mill he’d discovered some time ago. The place was hidden away and seemed ideal for the kind of photos we loved taking—rustic spaces with that raw, forgotten feel. We entered casually through the front, our cameras ready, aiming to capture as much as we could before moving on to the other buildings. About 20 minutes into our shoot, J’s voice broke the silence. “There’s a white truck out front.” He’d spotted it from the second-floor window. I joined him, snapping a few more pictures along the way, trying to stay calm. We figured maybe it was someone stopping by briefly. But just as I was getting my last shot in, I saw movement at the entrance. A man stepped inside, chatting on the phone. Alarmed, J and I ducked behind a wall, hearts racing. Before we knew it, three more people had joined him—a second man, a woman, and a small dog. We realized, with sinking dread, that it was the property owner, likely giving contractors a tour and get...
Read more

Derby Feed Company

Image
  In Derby, a quiet transformation has taken place, one that tells a story of economic ambition, missed opportunities, and a community left to wonder what might have been. Back in 2016, the site of the former Derby Garden Center and Derby Feed Co. was little more than a memory. The buildings had already been torn down, leaving behind rocky soil and empty foundation pads. The only remnant of the feed company’s once-busy operation was a towering grain silo at the back of the property. Its ladder hooks had been sawed off, ensuring no adventurous climber could scale the now-defunct structure. For years, the silo stood as a symbol of the company’s legacy—a place that had provided feed materials to countless customers. But even that was eventually removed, demolished by the city to make the land more appealing to developers eager for a clean slate. Fast forward to December 2024, and the site has found a new purpose as a home for a construction materials business. Yet, the surrounding are...
Read more

Former 75th Police Precinct Station House Renovated

Image
Update May 27, 2024: On a brisk Monday, March 4th, 2024, a beacon of hope and care emerged at 486 Liberty Avenue in East New York. This new facility, established by Care For the Homeless , is set to be a cornerstone in the community, offering a sanctuary for 157 homeless men grappling with mental illness. Beyond just providing beds, this site encompasses an Article 28 community health center, dedicated to addressing the primary medical care and behavioral health needs of both its residents and the broader community. Under the stewardship of a seasoned director, the shelter will employ a robust team of 76 professionals. This team includes social workers, case managers, housing specialists, and a vigilant 24/7 security and maintenance crew, all committed to fostering a supportive and secure environment for the residents. The health center will be a lifeline for many, operating five days a week and staffed by a multidisciplinary team. This includes a physician, nurse, medical assistan...
Read more

Potter Hill Mill of Westerly Rhode Island

Image
  In my extensive ventures across various businesses, churches, factories, and plants, I've encountered a plethora of remnants from bygone industrial eras. Yet, none have left as profound an impression as the sight of the leftover machinery at the former Potter Hill Mill. Nestled amidst its surroundings, these aging relics stand as silent witnesses to a vibrant industrial past, their once-potent functionality now subdued by the relentless march of time. The manufacturing equipment, once the lifeblood of cotton goods production, remains steadfast, firmly bolted to the floor, slowly succumbing to the relentless embrace of rust and decay. It's a scene frozen in time—a rare glimpse into the mechanical marvels of the 1800s, preserved in their original state, untouched and unscathed by modern interventions. As I gaze upon the weather-worn structures and rusted machinery, I'm struck by the poignant juxtaposition of past and present. The former textile mill, once a bustling hub of...
Read more