Former East New York 75th Precinct Station (153rd Precinct)


Station House facing Liberty Avenue & Miller Avenue

Historical

Completed in 1891 the former Romanesque Revival style with Venetian and Noram Revival ornament structure was created by 'architect' George Ingram who is cited as the designer of the building. Architect Emile M. Grewe is also credited with having a hand in the collaboration. George Ingram was an assistant engineer in the Department of City Works in 1886 who was not a trained architect by trade. The building accommodated about 80 patrolmen, cells, and a stable via a passageway from the main building. Back then it was known as the 17th precinct (Originally 153rd precinct). 



Entrance to the horse stable.


Opening in 1892, the first detainee was John Pocahontas Smith who was arrested for public drunkness. In the 1930s it was renamed the 75th precinct until 1973 the precinct moved to the newer 75th precinct holdings on Sutter Ave. It then became the home to People's Baptist Church in 1975 purchased from the City. At the time the building was well over 125 years old. The owner and leader of the church, Rev. W.D. Cleveland, eventually could not keep up with repairs due to his health and the building changed hands in 2016.

In 2007, it was listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

Some of the ornaments remain affixed to the building but what remains after renovation remains to be seen.

Present

In 2012, the Rev. R. Simone Lord, the widow of People's Baptist Church leader mounted a $20 million dollar fundraiser to restore the former station house as a veteran's housing and domestic shelter. That fundraiser fell through. In 2015, the People's congregation found out an individual had illegally obtained the deed to the property. Eventually, it was resolved and corrected by court order.



"The Castle" building stands ready for continuing renovation as all windows have been boarded and secured. A new roof constructed as before there was none.  Department of Buildings notice outside states it was to be completed in the Summer of 2019 but yet still stands unfinished as of June 1, 2020. Its architectural sibling, the 68th Precinct, in Sunset Park, is being transformed into a grade school after standing vacant for quite some time since 1983. I went here a few years ago to see behind the imposing fortress building but found my entrance bricked when I returned the next day in the early morning hours. The property has had frequent incursions by the homeless. 


An undated Google Street View of the gut demolition.

Currently, the property is under the same owner who purchased the property in 2016. In New York real estate, an LLC. Here the member signing documents list the name of a well-known real estate developer in New York real estate development. 

Whilst photographing the exteriors as best as I could in harsh sunlight. A worker across the street informed me the owner had already replaced the missing roof and did a full gut of the 129-year-old building. He gave me some backstory on the first occupants and the previous owner as I have documented above in its sale. Nothing like street gossip to fill in the gaps!

View from Miller Avenue




As no surprise to anyone, the 75th Precinct on Sutter stands out as the most sued precinct in the city. It has paid out at least $9 million in settlements since 2015 and is involved in 91 federal lawsuits. Today's ongoing protests show that continuing police violence against people of color is still widely prevalent. 



Current Status: Commercial Renovation.

Address/Location: 484 Liberty Avenue, East New York

Coordinates: 40.6749723810013, -73.89200022513398







Sources:

Frishberg, Hannah, "Sunset Park's Landmarked Police Precinct Station: A Beautiful Ruin", November 30, 2015, Brownstoner

De Vries, Susan, "Preservationists in East New York Want to Shower Some Love on the Historic 75th Precinct Station", February 21, 2019, Brownstoner

Leonhardt, Andrea, "East New York's 75th Precinct is the City's Most Sued Precinct", March 13, 2019, BKReader

Fonville, Gary, "Former Station Houses", August 5, 2006, Forgotten NY

"Former 75th Police Precinct Station House", 6tocelebrate

Richardson, Clem, "Brooklyn church hopes to turn derelict former police precinct into vets' housing, domestic violence shelter", April 23, 2012, NYDailyNews

"Church Fortress Defying Brooklyn Decay", November 5, 1979,  NYTimes

Bad Guy Joe, "Brooklyn's Abandoned 68th and 75th Police Stations", May 9, 2016,  LTVSquad

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Inside the Old Remington Munitions Factory

Image
Over the years, I have had the opportunity to visit the Remington Munitions Factory three times, each visit a unique experience. The first time, I ventured there alone, driven by curiosity to explore what remained of the once-bustling industrial complex. Back then, the neighborhood was far from welcoming, and my solo exploration felt risky. However, the allure of the factory’s history and its remnants was too strong to resist. Upon arrival, the decay was evident. The complex was a shadow of its former self, ravaged by time and neglect. Scrap metal scavengers had stripped the buildings of valuable copper, steel, and iron. Every surface was a canvas for graffiti, a mix of juvenile doodles and more elaborate street art left by local kids and adventurous visitors. A fire in 2017 had already claimed part of one building, and the area had a reputation for violence, with frequent assaults and shootings on Barnum Avenue. Despite the deterioration, the factory had a certain haunting beauty, esp...
Read more

Hendey Machine Co.'s Historic Complex in Torrington

Image
  One warm day, J and I set off to explore an old mill he’d discovered some time ago. The place was hidden away and seemed ideal for the kind of photos we loved taking—rustic spaces with that raw, forgotten feel. We entered casually through the front, our cameras ready, aiming to capture as much as we could before moving on to the other buildings. About 20 minutes into our shoot, J’s voice broke the silence. “There’s a white truck out front.” He’d spotted it from the second-floor window. I joined him, snapping a few more pictures along the way, trying to stay calm. We figured maybe it was someone stopping by briefly. But just as I was getting my last shot in, I saw movement at the entrance. A man stepped inside, chatting on the phone. Alarmed, J and I ducked behind a wall, hearts racing. Before we knew it, three more people had joined him—a second man, a woman, and a small dog. We realized, with sinking dread, that it was the property owner, likely giving contractors a tour and get...
Read more

Derby Feed Company

Image
  In Derby, a quiet transformation has taken place, one that tells a story of economic ambition, missed opportunities, and a community left to wonder what might have been. Back in 2016, the site of the former Derby Garden Center and Derby Feed Co. was little more than a memory. The buildings had already been torn down, leaving behind rocky soil and empty foundation pads. The only remnant of the feed company’s once-busy operation was a towering grain silo at the back of the property. Its ladder hooks had been sawed off, ensuring no adventurous climber could scale the now-defunct structure. For years, the silo stood as a symbol of the company’s legacy—a place that had provided feed materials to countless customers. But even that was eventually removed, demolished by the city to make the land more appealing to developers eager for a clean slate. Fast forward to December 2024, and the site has found a new purpose as a home for a construction materials business. Yet, the surrounding are...
Read more

St. Michael and St. Edward Church: A Cornerstone of Fort Greene

Image
For weeks, I had been orbiting the perimeter of the impending demolition of the Church of St. Michael and St. Edward, a once revered church in the heart of Fort Greene, like a moth drawn to a flame. The neighborhood, a patchwork of tight project housing, seemed indifferent to the fate of this historic edifice. The intel I had received suggested that entry was as simple as scaling a wooden fence, yet the timing had never felt right. Until one day, it did. With a mission in New Jersey looming, I knew it was now or never. The demolition was advancing at a startling pace, the church's twin steeples already reduced to rubble. The skeletal remains of timber beams and rusted steel frames peeked out from the ruins, a testament to the relentless march of progress. Summoning a surge of courage, I seized a moment of quiet in the bustling housing project and vaulted over the fence. My heart pounded in my chest as I slipped unnoticed into the church grounds. The once grand entrance now stood as...
Read more

Former 75th Police Precinct Station House Renovated

Image
Update May 27, 2024: On a brisk Monday, March 4th, 2024, a beacon of hope and care emerged at 486 Liberty Avenue in East New York. This new facility, established by Care For the Homeless , is set to be a cornerstone in the community, offering a sanctuary for 157 homeless men grappling with mental illness. Beyond just providing beds, this site encompasses an Article 28 community health center, dedicated to addressing the primary medical care and behavioral health needs of both its residents and the broader community. Under the stewardship of a seasoned director, the shelter will employ a robust team of 76 professionals. This team includes social workers, case managers, housing specialists, and a vigilant 24/7 security and maintenance crew, all committed to fostering a supportive and secure environment for the residents. The health center will be a lifeline for many, operating five days a week and staffed by a multidisciplinary team. This includes a physician, nurse, medical assistan...
Read more